Controversy about UK's Holding Period for Terrorist Suspects - Why not use technology to enhance police capabilities?
April 14 2008 | 1 comment(s)

Jacqui Smith, the UK Home Secretary
recently stated that the terrorist threat is growing and threatens to overwhelm
the ability to police. These claims come as she is requesting that
parliament approve a change to the period for which terrorist suspects can be
held without charge from 28 to 42 days. Currently, in the
This need to hold an individual in custody without charge, highlights two
issues. Firstly, that today the detection of terrorists is a manpower
intensive job and the assumption on the part of those policing is that it isn't
going to change anytime soon. Nowhere in the debate concerning the
handling of suspects do we see mentioned the role of technology.
Secondly, there is the issue of civil rights.
The need for men on the ground in the detection and monitoring of terrorist
suspects will never be eliminated, but technological advances can make the
process less manpower intensive. Today we don't require
football fields of people listening for 'interesting' conversations on radio
frequencies as they did during World War II. Today, that and many aspects
of similar jobs are automated and handled almost entirely by computers.
The submissions to the annual Global Security Challenge have us convinced that
the possibility of reducing the manpower component of security monitoring is
promising.
The second issue is harder to address. In modern democracies, the
issue of taking an individual into custody without charge is fraught with
controversy and opens the debate of individuals' rights versus the public
safety. We are all familiar with situations abroad where political
opposition is dealt with by imprisonment or worse, and while this doesn't
happen in the
So how does a modern democracy balance the threat of terrorism, recognizing
that there are situations where arresting an individual can prevent a larger
tragedy, even though there isn't a case that can be successfully prosecuted at
the time of the arrest?
Previous articles
July 2008 - 14 article(s) | show
June 2008 - 21 article(s) | show
May 2008 - 20 article(s) | show
April 2008 - 12 article(s) | show
March 2008 - 7 article(s) | show
February 2008 - 8 article(s) | show
January 2008 - 9 article(s) | show
December 2007 - 1 article(s) | show
November 2007 - 8 article(s) | show
October 2007 - 11 article(s) | show
September 2007 - 6 article(s) | show
Comments
April 16 2008 11:30AM by spiderpig
i don't smith is listening to you. this artcile says uk is hiring more police.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7349364.stm
Leave a Comment